Songs that remind us of school

The Buzz · Buzzcasts · The Ultimate Mixtape

Rik and Jon each bring two songs that take them straight back to school: Marillion's "Kayleigh", The Stone Roses' "I Wanna Be Adored", The Jackson Sisters' "I Believe in Miracles" and Mott the Hoople's "All the Young Dudes". Expect a borrowed LP, a release-day queue, a 16th birthday party and a sixth-former who talked his school into its first covers gig.

Listen in the Vault on The Buzz app
Side A / Side BEP 01
  1. A1KayleighMarillion · Rik's pick
  2. A2I Wanna Be AdoredThe Stone Roses · Jon's pick
  3. B1I Believe in MiraclesThe Jackson Sisters · Rik's surprise
  4. B2All the Young DudesMott the Hoople · Jon's surprise
The Ultimate MixtapeSongs That Remind Us of School
In this episode

The short version

  • Four songs from 1972 to 1989 that take Rik and Jon straight back to school, from Marillion's "Kayleigh" to Mott the Hoople's "All the Young Dudes".
  • The stories behind them: the real Kay Lee, the David Bowie song Mott the Hoople turned down, and the 1973 soul flop that became the first song ever played on The Buzz.
  • Why album tracks and B-sides meant so much to their generation, and what streaming has done to them.
Running order

Two ways through the tape

Follow the show minute by minute, so you know where to skip to in the Vault. Or lay the songs and stories out by the year they happened.

ChatSide A pickSide B pick
0:14 – 6:26

What we've been listening to

Rik and Jon · 6 min
  • Rik has spent GCSE season driving his daughters 45 minutes each way to school, sometimes waiting two hours outside while they sat an exam. Music is the family's common language, so the car became his chance to introduce them to the classics.
  • Who controls the car stereo? Jon says it used to be the driver's call, because they're doing the work. Now the kids' first question is "Can I plug my phone in?"
  • Rik's daughters have had Olivia Rodrigo's new album, You Seem Pretty Sad for a Girl So in Love, on repeat. It includes "What's Wrong With Me", a duet with Robert Smith of The Cure, after the pair played together at Glastonbury and Primavera Sound. Rik had tried for years to get his daughters into The Cure, and they'd written Smith off on his looks. This duet is what finally won them over.
  • Jon, also a Cure fan, enjoyed clips of Rodrigo and Smith talking about songwriting. Rik shares her story: she grew up on her dad's Cure obsession, and later got to watch him meet Robert Smith.
  • Jon's week was one album on repeat on his dog walks: Inferno, Boards of Canada's first album in 13 years. Rik says waiting for an album from an artist you trust still feels like going to the record shop on release day.
6:26 – 8:23

The theme: songs that remind us of school

Rik and Jon · 2 min
  • Watching their kids go through GCSEs sends Rik and Jon back to their own. Rik sat his in 1988, the first year of the exam. Jon thinks he was in the first or second year; his school oddly split them across two years.
  • Rik's kids had never worked out why it's called sixth form: school used to run from first year to fifth year, and the sixth form came next.
8:23 – 18:15

Kayleigh · Marillion

Rik's pick · 10 min

Rik plays Marillion's 1985 hit and tells how a borrowed concept album took a 12-year-old pop kid somewhere new.

Go to the track ↓
18:15 – 27:24

I Wanna Be Adored · The Stone Roses

Jon's pick · 9 min

Jon queued on release day for the Roses' debut. He and Rik argue over whether its opening track is arrogance or irony.

Go to the track ↓
27:24 – 29:35

Album tracks, B-sides and streaming

Rik and Jon · 2 min
  • Rik points out that "I Wanna Be Adored" wasn't a single when the album came out, yet everyone their age knows it. The Buzz plays album tracks like that for exactly this reason.
  • Jon mentions The Cure's recent gig in Spain, where the crowd sang along to old B-sides that never made an album.
  • Rik reckons Oasis were the last band to treat B-sides properly, with enough good ones to fill a whole album.
  • Now, says Jon, "Spotify's killed it": a single comes with an EP of remixes by guest producers instead of a proper extra song.
Go to The conversation ↓
29:35 – 38:11

I Believe in Miracles · The Jackson Sisters

Rik's surprise · 9 min

Side B starts here, with the surprise picks. Rik's is a 1973 soul flop he first heard at a 16th birthday party, and the first song The Buzz ever played.

Go to the track ↓
38:11 – 48:08

All the Young Dudes · Mott the Hoople

Jon's surprise · 10 min

Jon's sixth-form hero George, a school covers gig, and the hit David Bowie gave away.

Go to the track ↓
48:08 – 48:39

Wrap

Rik and Jon · under 1 min
  • Rik and Jon reckon their school years were such a peak for listening that they could fill a whole series with school songs.
  • Rik sums up Marillion, The Stone Roses, Mott the Hoople and The Jackson Sisters as "pretty eclectic". Next week: four new tunes and a new theme.
Side A song releasedSide B song releasedA memoryThis week's listening
1972

"All the Young Dudes" saves Mott the Hoople

Jon's surprise

David Bowie's gift to a band about to split reaches No. 3 in the UK.

Go to the track ↓
1973

The Jackson Sisters release "I Believe in Miracles"

Rik's surprise

It flops on release, and nobody yet knows it will have a second life.

Go to the track ↓
1985

"Kayleigh" hits No. 2, and Rik borrows the album

Rik's pick

A schoolfriend lends 12-year-old Rik Misplaced Childhood, and his listening changes for good.

Go to the track ↓
Mid '80s

George sings "All the Young Dudes" at school

A memory

Jon is 13 or 14 when his sixth-form hero talks the staff into a covers concert.

Go to the track ↓
1988

The first GCSEs, and a 16th birthday party

A memory

Rik sits his GCSEs in the exam's first year, and hears "I Believe in Miracles" for the first time at a friend's 16th birthday party, after London's rare groove scene has revived it.

Go to the track ↓
1989

The Stone Roses release their debut album

Jon's pick

Jon, 16, queues outside the shop on release day for the album that opens with "I Wanna Be Adored".

Go to the track ↓
1991

"I Wanna Be Adored" finally becomes a UK single

From the B-sides chat

It reaches No. 20, two years after everyone their age already knew it by heart.

2020

The Buzz launches with "I Believe in Miracles"

A memory

On 16 August 2020, Rik's party song plays at the countdown: the first track the station ever played.

2025

Olivia Rodrigo brings Robert Smith on stage at Glastonbury

This week's listening

They play "Just Like Heaven" and "Friday I'm in Love" together: the start of the partnership that wins over Rik's daughters.

2026

Inferno, "What's Wrong With Me", and another GCSE season

This week's listening

Boards of Canada release their first album in 13 years, Rodrigo and Smith release their duet, and Rik and Jon relive exam season through their kids.

The tracks

Four songs, four school memories

Each pick has two stories: what it meant to Rik or Jon, and the story of the song itself.

Side AKnown picks. Each host knew what was coming.
A1Rik's pick1985

Kayleigh – Marillion (1985)From the album Misplaced Childhood

The memory

At 12, Rik was a chart-pop kid. It was Duran Duran and Howard Jones, and he and his mate Adam were running a mobile disco stocked with the hits of the early '80s. Then a schoolfriend called Adam, who had an older brother, brought Marillion's Misplaced Childhood into school and told Rik to take it home.

The artwork was like nothing he'd seen. Albums meant saving up and choosing carefully, and this one was a concept album: every track runs into the next, and the story carries on when you turn the record over. It blew his mind, and it led him to the prog records in his mum and dad's collection. "Kayleigh" sums up that whole summer for him.

The song

Fish wrote the lyric, the rest of Marillion wrote the music, and Chris Kimsey produced it at Hansa Studios in Berlin. The first single from Misplaced Childhood, "Kayleigh" entered the UK chart on 18 May 1985 and reached No. 2, kept off the top by The Crowd's charity version of "You'll Never Walk Alone". It's still Marillion's biggest hit. The album followed on 17 June 1985 and went to No. 1, the band's only chart-topping album. Fish split up with a girlfriend called Kay and added her middle name, Lee; he has said the song draws on three or four relationships. He says the album's concept came during an LSD trip, after an old girlfriend posted him a tab. Fish sang with the band from 1981 until he left in 1988.

Sources: Kayleigh · Louder: the story behind Kayleigh · Louder: Misplaced Childhood · Fish

"This album and this song was the doorway for me discovering much more varied types of music."Rik
Hear it in the Vault from 08:23"Kayleigh" on Spotify
A2Jon's pick1989

I Wanna Be Adored – The Stone Roses (1989)Opening track of the album The Stone Roses

The memory

Jon was 16, living in Manchester but away at boarding school, and devouring the NME and Melody Maker. He'd read about the band's secret gigs and was already into the Pixies and The Cure when baggy, the Happy Mondays and the Haçienda took over. He queued outside the shop on release day, then played the album 20 or 25 times straight through.

He loves the minute of near-nothing before it starts ("come on, start!"). Jon hears pure arrogance in a band opening their first album with "I Wanna Be Adored". Rik thinks Ian Brown meant it as both swagger and irony. Either way, they agree that refusing to play the shiny '80s PR game only added to the mystique.

The song

Ian Brown and John Squire wrote "I Wanna Be Adored", and the band were playing it live as early as 1985. John Leckie produced it in night sessions at Battery Studios in London, and it opens The Stone Roses, released on Silvertone Records on 2 May 1989. The song fades up from a wash of noise and builds from Mani's bassline before Brown sings a lyric of barely a dozen words. It wasn't released as a UK single when the album came out. Silvertone put it out in the US, where it reached No. 18 on Billboard's Modern Rock chart in 1990, and in the UK in September 1991, where it reached No. 20 and later went Platinum.

Sources: I Wanna Be Adored · The Stone Roses (album) · Radio X

"It's not really, frankly, much of a song. There's about what, ten or twelve words in it."Jon
Hear it in the Vault from 18:15"I Wanna Be Adored" on Spotify
Side BSurprise picks. Neither knew the other's choice.
B1Rik's surprise1973

I Believe in Miracles – The Jackson Sisters (1973)Written by Mark Capanni

The memory

It was 1988, a friend's 16th birthday party in a big house, with two lads from school on the decks playing the usual pop hits. Then that long drum intro came on, and Rik stopped dead with his back to the DJ. He can still picture exactly where he was standing. He insists on the full version, because the radio edit loses the magic.

He's been obsessed with it ever since. When The Buzz launched on 16 August 2020, this was the song that played at the countdown: the first track the station ever played. As Rik remembers it, Bobby Taylor didn't just produce the group but put them together. Jon loves that the groove was played by a real drummer, probably in one or two takes.

The song

The Jackson Sisters were five sisters born in Compton, California, and based in Detroit, with no relation to the Jackson 5. Mark Capanni wrote "I Believe in Miracles" and recorded his own version, but theirs came out first, on the small Prophesy label in 1973. Bobby Taylor, the singer who had championed the Jackson 5 at Motown, produced it. It barely touched the US R&B chart, and the sisters stopped performing together in 1975. Its second life came from London's rare groove scene of DJs, warehouse parties and pirate radio: a reissue reached No. 72 on the UK chart in June 1987. Public Enemy sampled it for "Can't Do Nuttin' For Ya Man" in 1990, and Basement Jaxx and Arrested Development have used it too.

Sources: The Jackson Sisters · Expansion Records · Mr Bongo reissue notes

"It was a stop-me-in-my-tracks moment."Rik
Hear it in the Vault from 29:35"I Believe in Miracles" on Spotify
B2Jon's surprise1972

All the Young Dudes – Mott the Hoople (1972)Written and produced by David Bowie

The memory

At Jon's sporty, all-boys boarding school, a sixth-former called George hated sport, loved old music and walked the corridors singing without caring who heard. He played Bowie, the Beatles, Bob Dylan and this song constantly, and he got 13-year-old Jon into all of it.

Covers concerts weren't done at the school, but George talked the staff into one anyway. He sang "All the Young Dudes" with a makeshift band of teenage musicians, and Jon still remembers how good he was. Today, Jon's own son listens to more Bob Dylan than Jon ever did. Jon credits Lou Reed with calling it a gay anthem, and Rik believes it was the first song Bowie wrote for anyone else.

The song

Mott the Hoople, a hard rock band, split up on 26 March 1972 after a dismal gig in Zurich. David Bowie offered them "Suffragette City", which they turned down, so he wrote and produced "All the Young Dudes" for them instead. CBS released it on 28 July 1972; it reached No. 3 in the UK and saved the band. Bowie later said the young dudes carry news of the end of the world, and many have heard it as a gay anthem. Rolling Stone ranks it No. 166 of the 500 greatest songs. For BBC airplay, singer Ian Hunter re-sang the line naming Marks & Spencer, because brand names counted as advertising. It wasn't Bowie's first gift to another act: Peter Noone took his "Oh! You Pretty Things" to No. 12 in 1971.

Sources: All the Young Dudes · Blender, October 2004 · Oh! You Pretty Things

"He wasn't trying to break the rules. He was just trying to do something that was never done before."Jon, on George
Hear it in the Vault from 38:11"All the Young Dudes" on Spotify
The conversation

What the songs got us talking about

The car is where music gets passed on

Rik spent GCSE season driving his daughters 45 minutes each way to school. After years of failing to sell them The Cure, it was Olivia Rodrigo's duet with Robert Smith, "What's Wrong With Me", that finally won them over. Rodrigo got The Cure from her own dad's car stereo. Jon's son now loves Bob Dylan more than Jon does. Every generation picks up its music from the one before, and the fight is over who gets to plug their phone in.

Hear it in the Vault from 00:14

The story sells the song

Boards of Canada, two Scottish brothers who never give interviews, teased Inferno, their first album in 13 years, with grainy VHS-style clips. Jon thinks the mystique matters as much as the music. Rik goes further: he finds it hard to really love a band without knowing their story, which is exactly why Fish and Kay Lee, or Bowie handing away a hit, make these songs hit harder.

Hear it in the Vault from 04:11 and 17:39

Songs used to take their time

A guitar solo that goes on and on in "Kayleigh". A minute of atmosphere before "I Wanna Be Adored" gets going. Nearly a minute of pure drum groove before the Jackson Sisters sing. None of these songs rushes to a chorus at the 2:30 mark, and Rik and Jon reckon that's exactly why they've lasted.

Hear it in the Vault from 15:03

Album tracks mattered, and streaming killed the B-side

A whole generation knows "I Wanna Be Adored" note for note, though it wasn't a single when the album came out. Crowds at Cure gigs still sing along to B-sides from 30 years ago, and Rik reckons Oasis were the last band whose B-sides were good enough to fill an album. Now, as Jon puts it, "Spotify's killed it": a single comes with a remix EP, not a proper extra song.

Hear it in the Vault from 27:24

Swagger beats polish

After the glitz, make-up and big hair of Duran Duran and Spandau Ballet, The Stone Roses turned up surly, dressed for the pub and refused to do the TV rounds. At Jon's school, George ignored what the staff said was possible and put on a gig anyway. Not doing as you were told runs through both stories, and it worked both times.

Hear it in the Vault from 25:36 and 38:32

Questions

Questions this episode answers

What was the first song ever played on The Buzz?

According to Rik, it was "I Believe in Miracles" by The Jackson Sisters, which played at the countdown when The Buzz launched on 16 August 2020. He picked it as his Side B surprise in Episode 1.

Who is "Kayleigh" by Marillion about?

Marillion's singer Fish had dated a woman called Kay Lee, and the song is named after her. Fish has also said the lyric draws on several past relationships, not just one.

Was "I Wanna Be Adored" by The Stone Roses ever a single?

Yes, but not when the album came out in May 1989. It was released as a single in the US first, then in the UK in September 1991, where it reached No. 20.

Did David Bowie write "All the Young Dudes"?

Yes. Bowie wrote and produced it for Mott the Hoople in 1972, after they turned down "Suffragette City". It reached No. 3 in the UK and saved the band from splitting up.

Why did the BBC change a lyric in "All the Young Dudes"?

The original line names Marks & Spencer, and the BBC treated brand names as advertising. Singer Ian Hunter re-recorded the line for BBC airplay.

What was the rare groove scene?

A London scene of the late 1980s, when DJs, warehouse parties and pirate radio stations dug up overlooked funk and soul records from the '60s and '70s. It's how The Jackson Sisters' 1973 flop "I Believe in Miracles" became a classic and reached the UK chart in 1987.

Heard on the show

Every song in the conversation

The picks

  • "Kayleigh" – MarillionA1 · Rik's pick · 1985Spotify
  • "I Wanna Be Adored" – The Stone RosesA2 · Jon's pick · 1989Spotify
  • "I Believe in Miracles" – The Jackson SistersB1 · Rik's surprise · 1973Spotify
  • "All the Young Dudes" – Mott the HoopleB2 · Jon's surprise · 1972Spotify

Also mentioned

  • "What's Wrong With Me" – Olivia Rodrigo and Robert SmithThe duet that won Rik's daughters over to The CureSpotify
  • You Seem Pretty Sad for a Girl So in Love – Olivia RodrigoThe album on repeat on Rik's GCSE school runsSpotify
  • Inferno – Boards of CanadaJon's album of the weekSpotify
  • "Boys Don't Cry" – The CureOne of Rik's gateway songs for his daughtersSpotify
  • "Friday I'm in Love" – The CureAnother of the poppy hits Rik eased inSpotify
  • Misplaced Childhood – MarillionThe borrowed album that opened Rik's earsSpotify
  • The Stone Roses – The Stone RosesThe debut Jon queued for on release day in 1989Spotify
  • "I Am the Resurrection" – The Stone RosesThe album's swaggering closerSpotify
  • "Suffragette City" – David BowieThe song Mott the Hoople turned downSpotify

Artists name-checkedDuran Duran, Howard Jones, Happy Mondays, Pixies, Spandau Ballet, Oasis, The Cure, The Beatles, Bob Dylan, Lou Reed, Iggy Pop, Public Enemy, Basement Jaxx, Arrested Development.

The Ultimate Mixtape playlist

Every pick from the show lives on our collaborative Spotify playlist, and you can add your own. What would make your school-days mixtape?

Add your song to the playlist
Your turn

What's your school song?

The one that takes you straight back to the playground, the bus or the sixth-form common room. Tell us, and it might end up on the show.

Tell us on WhatsApp +44 7488 600158
Transcript

Every word, minus the lyrics

Lightly edited for reading. Times match the episode in the Vault.

Read the full transcript 48 minutes · Rik and Jon

Rik: So how you doing, man?

Jon: Not too bad. Been a good week. How have you coped with the exam stress? We've both been going through it this week.

Rik: Oh, we're finished now, so that's the good news.

Jon: Thank God for that.

Rik: But I've never done more mileage in my car than I have in the last month, and the blessing of that is I've listened to a heck of a lot of music I wouldn't have had time for. The school my kids go to is 45, 50 minutes away, and because it's that far, I'd often sit outside and wait for her to finish her exam rather than going back and coming back again. So I could be 45 minutes in the car with the kids, two hours outside the school, and then another 45-minute journey back. Thankfully, music is our common language with the girls, and that's great. I feel like that's my moment to be the best parent I can be and introduce them to the absolute classics. But I don't always have full control over the playlist, unfortunately.

Jon: Yeah, that's an interesting one, who has control in the car. My rule always used to be it was the driver, right? They're doing the work. But with the kids, it's the first question they ask now, right? "Can I plug my phone in and take control?" So what have been the bonding tunes this week?

Rik: Well, this week it has been pretty much relentlessly, while they've been in the car, Olivia Rodrigo.

Jon: Yeah, new album just out, right?

Rik: New album out. A lot of anticipation from everybody, it seems. And I think me and you have spoken about this recently, but there's this masterstroke of Robert Smith and his relationship with her: him appearing on stage with her at Glastonbury and Primavera, and then them doing this duet on the new album. It's been amazingly good for me as a parent, because it's one of those "I told you so" moments. I've been trying to get them into The Cure for years. They looked him up, and if you look up Robert Smith and you don't know him, you're probably pretty freaked. Well, they were. He's pretty freaky-looking to them, so they dismissed him instantly based on how he looks. Then I'd ease a few tunes in slowly, "Boys Don't Cry", "Friday I'm in Love", the poppy hits, and that would win them over. Then I'd go a bit deeper, but it never really went in properly. But this Olivia Rodrigo collaboration has done wonders for me. Now they want to know everything about him.

Jon: Yeah, it's quite funny. You've sent me some clips, probably TikTok or something, of the two of them talking about their mutual love, how they're both these amazing songwriters. It definitely gives you goosebumps. You know I'm a Cure fan as well, so just listening to them talk about the songwriting, and she casually mentions, "I'm in England, and he invited me over to the studio", that kind of thing. And she's a fan. It'd just be so cool.

Rik: She told another story, I don't know if I sent it to you: her dad is the biggest Cure fan. That's why she's a Cure fan. He's obsessed with The Cure; that's pretty much all he played in the car when she was a kid. So then she gets to know Robert Smith and becomes friends with him, and there was a recent meeting where her dad got to meet him. She said watching her dad's face was worth everything. It's gorgeous. So what's your week been like, musically, emotionally?

Jon: I've had less time to listen to music this week, actually. I've had probably one album on repeat: the new Boards of Canada album.

Rik: Yeah, I haven't listened to it yet.

Jon: Well, I'm a massive electronic music fan, and an occasional writer of electronic music as well, and they're sort of legends in this sphere. They do no publicity, no interviews. They're this mystical… In fact, I only discovered this week that they're actually two Scottish brothers. I didn't even know where they were from. And they do this thing where they just drop hints. People have been asking whether they've got a new album out for the last few months, crikey, with these little clips, all retro, like old clips from TV, really grainy, almost video-cassette stuff. So there's been loads of hype, and then it finally dropped this week, and it's great. I like them, but it's the whole thing. They're quite old-fashioned, but they've got what you need today. It's about the story rather than necessarily the music. You could listen to some of the new album in isolation and think, well, it's not that special. But the whole story and mystique, and the fact they haven't released an album for years… It's been the one whenever I go out on my dog walk, which is usually my music listening time.

Rik: I'll give that a listen. You mentioned it a couple of weeks ago, and I think the day it was released you were full of anticipation. And I love that. When you trust an artist, there's nothing better. The expectation, the anticipation, reminds me of going to a record store the day an album came out. It's digital now and much easier to access, but when you have that faith in an artist and you're waiting for a release, it does still feel magical.

Jon: Yeah, totally agree. So on that note, should we dive back into the past slightly?

Rik: Yes. So the theme for this week, which we randomly settled on, was songs that remind me of school. Instantly nostalgic. It's been quite poignant for me, spending a lot of time at school and reliving GCSEs all over again. I was the first year of GCSEs, actually.

Jon: Oh wow. I think I was the second year. Oh no, I think I did some in the first year. Bizarrely, our school split GCSEs. I haven't heard of anyone doing this now, but you did a few in one year and a few more the next. I don't know why. That seems like it would make it much harder. So I think I was that first year and the second year of GCSEs, so we're probably about the same age.

Rik: So I think it must have been 1988 that I did them. But actually, the first track I'm going to play goes back to May 1985. I'd have been in the second year going into the third year. I know they've changed the numbers and now it's Year 9 or whatever, but back in our day it made sense: you went from first year to sixth form. It astounds my kids. They're in Year 11 going into sixth form, and I said, "You do know it's called sixth form because it used to be first year, second year, third year, fourth year, fifth year, then the sixth form?" And they're like, "Oh my God, I didn't know that."

Jon: I can never remember, by the way. If somebody asks what year my kids are in, I literally don't know the answer. I just have to say they're doing GCSEs this year or next.

Rik: Yeah, it has got very confusing. So the song I'm going to play is Marillion, "Kayleigh". I'll play the song first, and then we can revisit some of the memories.

"Kayleigh" by Marillion plays.

Jon: That's a proper blast from the past.

Rik: That is a proper blast from the past. The reason this was an odd tune for me is that I was very into pop music before it. '83, '84: Duran Duran, a lot of Howard Jones. The pop music was amazing. I was 11, 12, just taking it all in. Adam and me were running a mobile disco business as well, so we had a huge collection of the pop hits of '81, '82, '83. Then a kid at school, Adam, who had an older brother… we were in the second year going into the third year, and he brought this Marillion album in, Misplaced Childhood. The artwork was incredible, like nothing else I'd seen. He tried to explain this prog rock band: "Take this home and listen to it, you'll like it." I knew the single "Kayleigh", which had been in the charts, but the album wasn't something I'd normally buy. In those days, if you wanted an album you had to save up and make a very decisive choice about what you spent your money on. Anyway, I took the album home and it blew my mind. It's a concept album: every track blends into the next, and it's a proper A side and B side. The A side tells one part of the story, you turn the album over, and the whole second story unfolds. I wasn't used to that. I later discovered my mum and dad had loads of proggy rock albums in their collection, but I hadn't really touched them. I just fell in love with Marillion, and "Kayleigh" in particular typified that summer and that period of my life. I was 12, 13, starting to get into music that was a bit off-piste from where I'd been. This album and this song were the doorway for me discovering much more varied types of music, and that's why it's such a memorable piece for me. What do you remember about it?

Jon: Well, I remember the song. I don't remember much about the band, to be honest. I don't know how successful they were, but I can recall almost all the lyrics, so it was obviously on repeat somewhere. I don't think I ever bought it, but it's one of those classic songs, a really good, catchy track. It sounds fairly poppy today, even though it had this concept behind it, which I wasn't aware of. It's funny to hear a really long guitar solo in a track these days, because it's just not done anymore. And it went on for ages as well, right? It was really going to town.

Rik: That's four minutes of music, but it felt longer because it had the intro, it had the guitar solo. That's what songs were like for us. It didn't have to be two minutes thirty, straight in with the chorus. And the funny thing about this band is they were actually from Aylesbury, and their lead singer was called Fish, if you remember.

Jon: Oh yes, I do.

Rik: He wasn't with them for very long, four or five years maybe, and then he left at the peak of their fame. They got too successful after this: drugs and drink and touring and all the things you'd expect to go wrong, and he ended up leaving. They were a prog rock band, and the earlier albums I went on to discover were really dark and edgy, so this was a real departure for them, a pop single that charted. You could say it was the beginning of the end, because it sent them somewhere they hadn't expected to end up, and ultimately it changed the whole destiny of the band. Apparently it was written about an actual girl, Fish's girlfriend, Kay Lee. He asked her permission to use her name in the song. And apparently Kayleigh had sent him a present, a tab of acid in an envelope. He took the first half and it didn't do anything, so he took the second half, then it all kicked in and he went on this mental journey. That's allegedly where the concept album came from. So Kayleigh is quite pivotal in his story as well.

Jon: That's cool. Great to hear the story behind some of this stuff.

Rik: Yeah, because you get that context. For me, I find it difficult to really love a band if I don't know their story as well. The context of everything, the journey they go on musically or as friends, adds depth to the song itself, because you know where they were at in their journey.

Jon: Yeah, completely. Which is why we're in such a difficult place with music these days. Well, shall I play you my first song, then?

Rik: Yes, yes, yes.

Jon: So you may have heard of this song, and the listeners may have too. It's an absolutely enormous tune, but it was so important to me and my childhood. It came out in May 1989, so I was 16, and I'd been waiting for this album. It's one of the few I bought on the day of release. I was literally queuing outside to make sure I got hold of it. I must have played it back to back 20, 25 times, non-stop. Anyway, I'll take it away.

Rik: One of those intros that builds.

Jon: Yeah, it's a slow start. First track on the album.

"I Wanna Be Adored" by The Stone Roses plays.

Rik: Wow. Absolutely. That does something to me, that song.

Jon: Wow. It does me. I've got goosebumps listening to it. It's funny, because it's one of those songs that has been played to death now. Is it 30 years? '89. So yeah, it's been played to death, and there's a whole mythology about the band and this album, and the big gap to the next one. But none of that really means anything to me. Back then I was a massive consumer of the music press. I was really geeky about the NME and, was it Melody Maker, the other one?

Rik: Yeah.

Jon: So I read about these secret gigs this band from Manchester were doing. I was living in Manchester at the time, although away at school, so I was half in the Manchester camp. That's sort of my roots, even though I obviously don't sound like it. Unfortunately I don't have the accent like you do. I just loved everything about that whole movement, which I know with hindsight was sort of overhyped: the Manchester scene, the baggy scene, Happy Mondays, the Haçienda, all those bands. I was listening to the Pixies and The Cure, real indie stuff. And then this album came out, with that slow start. There's a minute where basically nothing happens. It's almost like atmosphere. You're desperate to hear it, you put it on and you're like, "Come on, start!" Now if you see them live, they usually start with it as the first song, and it just builds and builds. It's not really, frankly, much of a song. There are about ten or twelve words in it.

Rik: It's just pure mood, isn't it? Feeling.

Jon: That whole relaxed vibe, them not really dancing on stage. I can still picture him, I don't know what you'd call it…

Rik: The monkey man, that's what he was. Monkey king, whatever.

Jon: Yeah. And there's the arrogance of it: first album, first song, "I Wanna Be Adored", I'm going to be a superstar. I think he subsequently tried to downplay it and say it wasn't really about that, it was about how you shouldn't want to be adored, that it was a flaw in him and in everyone. But I think it was just arrogance. They thought, "We're going to be massive, we're going to come out with a bang." And that inspired the whole Oasis kind of swagger, but I think it started here.

Rik: Yeah, I agree with you. I think both of those ideas are true. It was braggadocio, "we are the best band in the world", that Manchester arrogance and swagger. But it was also ironic. He's a clever guy, Ian Brown, and there was an irony in there about ego and how people want attention. It was both. But when you saw them interviewed around this era, there was absolute arrogance. They didn't play the game. They didn't interview well. They were surly, rude, obnoxious. They didn't play the PR game at all, and that added to the mystique. We were used to pop stars being shiny and plastic and smiley, doing what they were told, doing the radio circuit, on every TV show. These guys didn't do that. They dressed like they were off the street. Baggy wasn't a conceived thing; it was just what they'd wear in the pub with their mates. We were coming off the '80s, bands like Duran Duran and Spandau Ballet, all glamour and glitz and make-up and big hair. Then these boys came along and said, "Nah, this is how we're doing it."

Jon: Yeah. Fantastic.

Rik: Just brilliant. The fact that it was the opening song… if it had been the sixth song, it might have lost some of its impact.

Jon: Yeah. Well, and then ending the album with "I Am the Resurrection". If they try to tell you it wasn't about arrogance, I think that shoots them in the foot.

Rik: Yeah. But this ties into the thing about the '80s. This was never a single, but everybody from our generation knows this song. And that doesn't happen anymore: album tracks as well known as, if not better known than, the singles. That was a sign of the times. Even on The Buzz, we play songs that were never singles but are known to everyone in our generation as if they were. I think that's really powerful, how important an album was.

Jon: Yeah. Well, you sent me the link to The Cure playing live in Spain just the other day, and some of the tracks they played were B-sides from singles they released on vinyl. And you can hear the crowd singing along. They know them, even though they're kind of forgotten, not on albums, just B-sides from singles released 20 or 30 years ago. I think that's amazing.

Rik: And that's the thing about a band like Oasis. As you mentioned Oasis before, they were probably the last band that properly respected the B-side. Some of their B-sides were better than their A-sides. They wrote so much material that the songs that weren't on albums became B-sides, and then they released an album of the B-sides because they were so good. I can't think of an artist who does that now. When a big artist releases a single on the streaming platforms, at best you might get a remix. Unless they call it an EP, where sometimes they release four or five tracks. But that's not the same as a B-side.

Jon: But even then it's usually remixes. Spotify's killed it. You need multiple releases. You can't throw all your good stuff on one release, because one of them might get lost. So you do an EP with two or three remixes and different versions from guest producers or something. Yeah, it's a bit of a shame.

Rik: Right. I'm going to move on to the next song. Part of the whole philosophy of the show is that we both know about each other's first choices, so we can prepare and think about our own stories, emotions and memories. But in the second half of the show, I play a song that reminds me of school that you don't know about, and vice versa. So this is my choice: the Jackson Sisters, "I Believe in Miracles".

"I Believe in Miracles" by The Jackson Sisters plays.

Jon: Whoa, that's a real blast from the past. When did that come out?

Rik: Well, there's an interesting story about it, actually, because it came out originally in like 1973 and completely flopped. It just didn't do anything at all. These were five sisters from Compton in California who were put together by a guy called Bobby Taylor, who'd been instrumental in the Jackson 5 era. He put together a girl group, not related to the Jacksons at all, a sort of antithesis to the Jackson 5, with five sisters. They recorded an album, put this track out, and it did nothing. It came and went, and within a couple of years the band disbanded and they went back to leading normal lives. But the weird thing was, in the '80s in London it was discovered by warehouse parties, rare groove and pirate radio stations, and it suddenly emerged out of nowhere and was everywhere. You probably knew it at the same time I did, around '88, '89, when it was rediscovered by the London warehouse scene. I was 16 and I wasn't at warehouse parties quite yet, but I was at a party: one of my friends' 16th birthday parties. He had quite a big house, there was a big gathering, and a couple of the boys from school said they'd DJ. They were playing all the usual classics you'd expect in 1988, a lot of poppy hits, and then suddenly that song came on. It was a stop-me-in-my-tracks moment. I had my back to the DJ; I can picture exactly where I was. The song came on with that intro, and the intro goes on for ages, doesn't it?

Jon: It does. Can you imagine making that track today? It must be almost a minute of just the groove.

Rik: Yeah. I could have played the radio edit, which is much more concise, but it loses its magic. Even the intro was enough to stop me: what is this? Then those voices come in and it just keeps building, the melody the girls are singing changes, and it grows and grows. That was it. I was in love with it, and I've been obsessed with that song ever since. In fact, it was the very first song we ever played on The Buzz when we launched on 16 August 2020. That was the song that played at the countdown.

Jon: It definitely holds a special place in your heart, then.

Rik: Yeah, yeah. Great tune.

Jon: Great tune. With my music producer hat on, there are so many bits of that I can hear in other tracks. People have definitely sampled it to death, right?

Rik: Yeah. Public Enemy sampled it. Basement Jaxx, I think. Arrested Development took bits of it. It's been sampled so many times.

Jon: But the drum groove… this was in the days when that was a human playing, probably in one or two takes, and it's totally amazing. Love it. Thanks for that.

Rik: So what's your surprise track? What are you going to hit me with?

Jon: My surprise choice. Well, mine's another old one, actually. Obviously we didn't talk about this. Mine's from 1972. I didn't hear it then, obviously; I wasn't born. I heard it when I was at school. A bit of background to set the scene: I was at boarding school, so we were in houses, and there was a guy in the sixth form in our house called George. Maybe I won't say his surname, because I've probably forgotten it anyway. He was very geeky. It was quite a sporty school, and he was so anti-sport, but he loved music, and he loved old music. As you can tell from my first choice, I wasn't really into old music. I was into the current indie stuff. He would listen to Bowie and the Beatles and this band I'm going to play, and Bob Dylan, of course, loads of that. And he got me into that whole scene. A bit like you with your kids and The Cure, my son now listens to more Bob Dylan than any modern stuff, much more than I ever did. Anyway, I was probably 13 or 14 when I first heard this, and this guy was my music hero. He was a singer. He'd always walk around singing and didn't care whether anybody heard him, at an all-boys school where walking around singing was probably not the most normal thing to do. He wanted to form a band and play covers. That wasn't done at the school, but he persuaded the staff to put on a concert. He got a band together and they played this track live, with him singing, in a makeshift band of teenage musicians. And he was amazing. Like, amazing. I still remember it. I knew the song quite well, because he played it all the bloody time before that. But he was one of the first people who was just like, "I don't care whether authority, in this case school teachers, says this is possible or not." He wasn't trying to break the rules. He was just trying to do something that had never been done before. He thought, "I'm going to do it, I'm going to persuade them, I'm going to put this on and it's going to be a success." And it was amazing.

Jon: Anyway, after all that preamble, this is "All the Young Dudes" by Mott the Hoople.

"All the Young Dudes" by Mott the Hoople plays.

Rik: You could just listen to him talking in that end bit for another ten minutes, wondering what's going to come out of his mouth.

Jon: Well, I just remember this guy George. Basically it's made for a live performance, isn't it? Because he's basically chatting to the audience at the end, and you could keep that going forever: "Hey, you at the back, I can see you." It's just brilliant. I'm not a Mott the Hoople fan; it's probably the only Mott the Hoople song I know. But what I discovered, doing a bit of research for this show, is that they were actually a hard rock band before this came out, and they were basically about to split up. They'd run out of ideas, they'd run out of fans. And Bowie wrote them some songs. He offered them "Suffragette City", which I think is a great song, and they said no, we don't like it, which I think is brilliant. Then he wrote them this, and it was a massive success, their biggest. It's such a fantastic sing-along anthem, with lots of different ways of interpreting it. When I was younger and first heard it, it was an anthem to youth, right? We're all in this together, a group of fans. Such a great sing-along chorus. I've since learned that Bowie came back and said it's more about an apocalyptic world, and the young dudes are actually carrying the news that the world is going to end and we've only got five years. And then Lou Reed, as he would, came out and said it's actually a gay anthem. Which is quite funny, these hard rockers singing a gay anthem. But whatever your interpretation, I think it's a classic tune.

Rik: It is. It's an absolute classic. I think what happens is they retrospectively fit stories to suit whatever narrative. Bowie was famously a chameleon. He changed every few years, not just his looks but his attitude, and he'd often look back on periods that had gone before, not with rose-tinted spectacles, or the opposite. Maybe there's a touch, not of bitterness as such, but he ended up writing a song that was a massive hit, not for him. And I think it was the first song he'd ever written for somebody else as well.

Jon: Yeah, I didn't know he did that much. So maybe it was one of the first and one of the last. I should dig into that a bit more.

Rik: Well, he did a lot of stuff for Lou Reed. He did write some stuff for Lou Reed as well, and maybe even Iggy Pop, I think. But it was definitely the first one he did, and it was a massive hit, so maybe it took him by surprise. But what a tune. You couldn't imagine Bowie doing it better. It had to be them: their energy, the lead singer's charisma.

Jon: Yeah, it really does carry. Fantastic swagger. And it's now in Rolling Stone's greatest songs of all time. Another great tidbit I found reading about this: there's a line about Wendy stealing clothes from Marks and Sparks. When they played it on the BBC they had to change it, because Marks and Sparks, M&S, was viewed as advertising. So they recorded a separate line just for the BBC, where she steals the clothes from unlocked cars instead. More criminal, but fine from an advertising point of view.

Rik: That's interesting. I've never heard that before. I wonder if that version exists, because that's the kind of version we'd play on The Buzz rather than the standard one.

Jon: Yeah, rare. Well, look it up: a BBC version.

Rik: Great tunes, though. Well, those are the songs that reminded us of school. We could probably do a whole series just on songs that remind us of school, I guess.

Jon: Probably. That was quite a peak, dense period for listening to music, wasn't it? Probably hundreds, if not thousands, of tunes we could pick out.

Rik: Thousands, yeah. And what have we got? Marillion, The Stone Roses, Mott the Hoople and the Jackson Sisters. Pretty eclectic.

Jon: It's a pretty good start to the Ultimate Mixtape.

Rik: Yeah, I think so. That was fun. I look forward to doing it next week with you, man. Four new tunes and a new theme.

Get the app

Every Buzzcast lives in the Vault

Listen to this episode, and every Ultimate Mixtape, in the Vault section of The Buzz app. It's free on iPhone and Android.

On a computer? Download The Buzz app on your phone, then open the Vault.

Every Buzzcast lives in the Vault

Hear every episode in the Vault section of The Buzz app. It's free on iPhone and Android.